A lived-in apartment in window light, with a red chair, a wooden table, and the city outside.
A lived-in apartment in window light, with a red chair, a wooden table, and the city outside.

A brochure yield names a city and a percentage. It rarely names the empty month, the management fee, the short-let ban, or the withholding that hits rent before it reaches a non-resident account. Those costs and rules decide whether a place works as a rental.

This page is the rental cut of How to choose a city for real estate investment. The job is income you can receive under current letting rules. Ownership clearance for non-residents belongs on Foreign and non-resident buyer rules, not here. Realtopedia has not yet built a comparable net-yield matrix across enough countries to publish a ranked rental-city list. Until that matrix reaches roughly twelve to fifteen countries, this guide stays with five markets and with rules that can be cited to an official page.

What “best for rentals” has to mean

“Best for rentals” means what remains after vacancy, management, maintenance, local tax, and the tenant rulebook have had their turn. A seat on a prime-price survey often means the asking price is high and the rent is thin relative to that price. How to read those surveys is a separate task on How to read a prime-price survey. A rental page has to cost the occupied unit, the empty month, and the clause that decides whether the landlord can regain the flat.

Before a city name enters serious notes, write the purpose in one plain line. You want net rent you can receive, in a currency you have decided to hold, from a unit you can let again and eventually sell. If that line cannot be said about the place, neighbourhood appeal alone is not enough for a rental decision.

A sunlit living room with a grey sofa, a wooden table, and several houseplants.
A sunlit living room with a grey sofa, a wooden table, and several houseplants.

Checks that weigh more when the job is rent

Use the same seven checks as the cities method. When the property is supposed to pay you, these are the checks that decide the result.

  1. Net income, with the guesses marked. Start from gross rent. Subtract vacancy, management, maintenance, insurance, local property tax, and a month you might not fill. A brochure yield is the top of that sum, not the result.
  2. The tenant rulebook. Notice periods, rent caps, deposit limits, and how a possession claim actually proceeds. A high gross figure in a city where you cannot regain the unit is a different investment from the one in the spreadsheet.
  3. Who operates it. A rental you will rarely visit needs a manager, a standard for repairs, and a way to know the rent arrived. Distance is a cost even when the model ignores it.
  4. The stock tenants rent. Completions of that unit type, not a crane count and not the trophy sample. The count that matters is the unit a tenant can actually rent.
  5. Short lets versus a tenancy. If the yield in the pitch depends on nightly stays, read the current short-let rule before you believe the yield. A ban, a licence, or a day-cap removes the number the brochure used.
  6. An exit for an income asset. The buyers of a let unit are a different pool from buyers who want a home. Resale for let units can be thin.
  7. Currency. Rent arrives in the city’s currency. If you spend in another, the extra income has to pay for that second result. That second result is written more fully in International real estate investing.

Five markets, letting rules only

The sections below are five places where official letting and rental-tax rules can be dated today. Ownership access, purchase taxes, and who may buy at all stay on the foreign-buyer matrix. A real rental-city ranking waits until comparable sourced facts cover roughly twelve to fifteen countries.

Singapore

Private residential stock faces a hard floor on stay length. The Urban Redevelopment Authority requires occupants to fulfil a minimum stay of three consecutive months; short-term accommodation under that threshold is not allowed (URA, renting property, read 2026-09-26).

Non-resident individuals who receive Singapore rental income are taxed at a flat 24% on that income from YA 2024, and non-residents who derive Singapore income must file regardless of amount (IRAS individual income tax rates, read 2026-09-26). This page does not claim a separate tenant withholding tax on immovable residential rent.

Australia

Foreign owners of residential dwellings must lodge an annual vacancy fee return with the Australian Taxation Office. A fee applies when a dwelling is vacant for 183 or more days in a vacancy year, or when the return is late; for vacancy years starting from 9 April 2024 the fee is double the foreign-investment application fee, and residential occupancy generally requires leases or availability of 30 days or more (ATO vacancy fee return, updated 17 March 2026, read 2026-09-26).

Holding costs also move with state land-tax surcharges. Victoria’s absentee owner surcharge is 4% from the 2024 land tax year, on top of general land tax (Victoria SRO, updated 23 September 2026, read 2026-09-26). New South Wales charges surcharge land tax on foreign persons’ residential land with no tax-free threshold, at 5% of land value from land tax year 2025 onwards (Revenue NSW, updated 8 April 2026, read 2026-09-26). Other states are not claimed here.

England and Northern Ireland

Landlords who spend more than six months abroad must handle UK rental income through HMRC’s Non-Resident Landlord Scheme. Letting agents, and tenants paying more than £100 a week, must deduct basic-rate tax unless HMRC authorises payment gross (HMRC guidance, read 2026-09-26). That scheme applies to UK property, including Northern Ireland.

Tenancy reform is not the same story in both places. The Renters’ Rights Act 2025 is primary legislation, and Phase 1 for England’s private rented sector, including abolition of section 21 “no fault” evictions and conversion to assured periodic tenancies, came into force on 1 May 2026 under commencement regulations (Renters’ Rights Act 2025; SI 2026/421; MHCLG roadmap, read 2026-09-26). Northern Ireland’s private-rented regime is separate; this page does not treat the England Phase 1 change as NI law.

Germany

Berlin treats holiday letting of Wohnraum as a change of use that generally needs prior Bezirksamt approval and a registration number shown in advertisements. Owner-occupied Hauptwohnungen may be approved for temporary holiday letting during absences if the residential character is kept; Nebenwohnungen are generally capped at 90 days a year with a permit; a single room of no more than 49% of floor area in a self-occupied Hauptwohnung needs a prior free notification rather than a full permit (Berlin Senate, Zweckentfremdungsverbot, read 2026-09-26).

Rent from German immovable property is domestic income for limited tax liability under EStG § 49 Abs. 1 Nr. 6 (gesetze-im-internet.de, read 2026-09-26). Ordinary property rent is assessment-based. This page does not invent a flat non-resident rate.

Japan

Under the Private Lodging Business Act, a notified residential lodging business may not exceed 180 days of lodging per year, counted per dwelling from noon on 1 April to noon on 1 April the next year. Municipal ordinances may tighten that ceiling further (MLIT / Japan Tourism Agency minpaku overview, read 2026-09-26).

When rent for Japan-situated real estate is paid to a non-resident or foreign corporation, the payer must generally withhold 20.42% (income tax plus reconstruction surtax, with further defence special income tax from Reiwa 9). Individuals renting for their own or relatives’ residence need not withhold (NTA Tax Answer No. 2880, laws as of 1 April Reiwa 8 / 2026, read 2026-09-26). Treaty relief may apply with prior filing.

Quick comparison (sourced rules only)

MarketLetting / short-stay floor or cap (official)Non-resident rental tax touchpoint (official)
SingaporePrivate: 3-month minimum stay (URA).Non-resident individuals: flat 24% on rental income from YA 2024; filing required (IRAS).
AustraliaVacancy fee if dwelling vacant 183+ days in a vacancy year; 30+ day occupancy standard (ATO).Holding: VIC absentee surcharge 4%; NSW foreign surcharge land tax 5% from 2025 (state revenue offices).
England / NIEngland PRS Phase 1 from 1 May 2026: no section 21; assured periodic tenancies (Act + SI). NI housing law separate.UK Non-Resident Landlord Scheme; basic-rate deduction unless HMRC allows gross (HMRC).
Germany (Berlin focus)Holiday letting of Wohnraum generally needs Bezirksamt permit + registration number; Nebenwohnung often max 90 days/year (Berlin Senate).Rental from German real estate is limited-tax domestic income under EStG § 49 (1) Nr. 6.
JapanMinpaku lodging business ≤180 days/year per notified dwelling; locals may tighten (MLIT).Payer generally withholds 20.42% on rent to non-residents, with an owner-occupier tenant exception (NTA).
An empty café terrace of metal chairs on a residential city street.
An empty café terrace of metal chairs on a residential city street.

Roles rentals play

People say “rental city” as if the label ranked places. In practice the label covers situations that do not pay you in the same way.

  • Income markets. Rent relative to price is the attraction. The work is still the netting, and then the currency.
  • Deep resale markets. An ordinary let flat can often be sold without hunting for a singular buyer. The rent while you hold it is still the part that tends to feel thin.
  • Rule-heavy markets. The tenant rulebook, the tax, or a surcharge can erase what a spreadsheet still shows as gross rent.
  • Short-let markets. The pitch is a nightly rate. That investment exists while the short-let use is lawful and while the nights are actually filled. Price the tenancy you would be left with if either condition failed.

When a city note can carry net income, the rules, and the operator in sourced detail, it belongs under Cities and markets. Until then, leave it off that index.

Where the other work sits

Choosing the city is still the seven checks in How to choose a city for real estate investment. Owning across a border adds currency, loans, and tax home, which is International real estate investing. Whether a non-resident may own, let, or borrow at all is a separate research task on Foreign and non-resident buyer rules.

Limits

This is a research guide for rental property under dated official letting and tax rules. It is not a recommendation to buy, let, or borrow, and it is not a forecast of rents. It does not know your tax residency or whether you can manage a building you will rarely visit. Confirm every claim with a qualified professional in the place. Sources were read on 2026-09-26.